Penang chief minister Chow Kon Yeow has accused his predecessor Lim Guan Eng of misleading the public over the proposed RM24.6 billion bulk water supply agreement with Perak, saying the 40-year deal protects the state’s water security. Chow called it irresponsible for Lim, the Bagan MP, to set aside repeated explanations of the agreement between the Penang Water Supply Corporation (PBAPP) and Perak’s water and irrigation agency, FMT wrote.
The payment splits into RM8.4 billion in capacity charges and RM16.2 billion in water supply charges across the 40 years, figures set out by Pocket News show. The agreement would bring between 300 million and 500 million litres of treated water a day into Penang.
The deal drew 98 per cent of votes cast at an extraordinary general meeting of PBA Holdings Bhd on 12 November. Chow said the state assembly debated the matter at two earlier sittings and that assemblymen were briefed by PBAPP. Perak will carry the construction, financing and maintenance risks, he said, while Penang pays only for water delivered to agreed standards.
Penang’s surface water resources will be fully used by 2030, and demand is expected to pass 1,100 million litres a day by 2032. A desalination plant able to produce 300 million litres a day was the next option examined by the state, and The Vibes put its cost above RM25 billion across construction and about 20 years of operation.
Lim answered today, saying his objection was to the financial terms rather than to sourcing water from Perak, which he said he began while he was chief minister. In a statement carried by Malay Mail, he said five independent directors of PBA Holdings had objected in writing to PBAPP’s obligation to pay Perak RM210 million a year for 40 years from 2032, even if no treated water is supplied.
Lim also disputed Chow’s account of the assembly debates, saying the full agreement had not been disclosed because of non-disclosure provisions. He has questioned the tariff, saying the opening rate of RM1.70 per cubic metre could reach RM7.21 across the contract, with further revisions possible after 22 years.
Under the deal, Perak’s agency will supply the treated water through a dedicated 500 million litre a day treatment plant estimated at RM3 billion to build. PBAPP is not required to make an upfront payment or capital contribution. Chow said the contract also allows Penang to end it under certain conditions, without saying which.
The agreement itself has not been published in full. Both men say they support finding water outside Penang, and neither has set out what happens if Perak misses a delivery.


