The Court of Appeal has reserved its decision on businessman Tan Sri Tan Kok Ping’s appeal against a High Court order that he pay RM350,000 in damages to Penang Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow for defamation. A three-member panel heard submissions in Putrajaya on 18 Nov and deferred its ruling to an unstated date, The Star reported.
Justices Datuk Azizul Azmi Adnan, Datuk Aliza Sulaiman and Datuk Seri Latifah Mohd Tahar sat on the panel. Tan was represented by Datuk K Kirubakaran, while K Simon Murali appeared for Chow.
Kirubakaran argued that the High Court judge had erred in law and fact in finding three Mandarin words defamatory. He said Chow had pleaded only the Malay translations of the remarks in his statement of claim, then widened their meaning in his witness statement and gave them a more injurious reading than the one he had pleaded.
Chow should be bound by his pleadings, Kirubakaran submitted, adding that the wider meaning prejudiced Tan. He also said the judge had erred in accepting Chow’s own explanation of what the words meant. “There was an absence of evidence from members of the community or third parties or experts on Chinese language as to the meaning and effect of the impugned statement on Chow,” he said.
Simon Murali urged the court to dismiss the appeal. He submitted that the High Court judgment was beyond reproach and contained no appealable errors, that the finding of malice was correct, and that Tan’s defences of justification, qualified privilege and fair comment were rightly rejected.
On 3 Dec 2024, Penang High Court judge Datuk Quay Chew Soon ordered Tan to pay the damages after ruling that remarks he made at a press conference on 18 Oct 2023 were defamatory. The words, spoken in Mandarin, were translated as “incompetent”, “ignorant” and “shameless”, and were published by six Chinese-language newspapers and an English-language daily. The court also awarded RM50,000 in costs, Malay Mail wrote at the time.
Quay found that Chow had satisfied all three elements of defamation, that the defences of justification, fair comment and qualified privilege were not proven, and that Tan had acted with malice. The chief minister “must be perceived as capable and intelligent in the performance of his duties”, the judge said, and “must command respect from the people of Penang”.
Chow filed the suit in January 2024 over remarks Tan made about the sale of state land in Batu Kawan. Tan is life honorary president of the Penang Chinese Chamber of Commerce. The press conference concerned the joint development agreement for the BKIP2 project, which had already been terminated by the time Tan spoke.
Chow was also represented by lawyers Kek Boon Wei, Lee Wen Qian, Fatimatuz Zahra Suhaimi and S Sharanya.


