Court of Appeal upholds dismissal of negligence suit against Penang General Hospital

Featured

The Court of Appeal on 16 November upheld, Malay Mail reported, the High Court’s dismissal of a medical negligence suit brought by a former religious teacher against the government and 31 medical personnel and staff of Penang General Hospital, where he was treated after a road accident in 2020.

A three-member bench chaired by Justice Datuk Dr Shahnaz Sulaiman, with Justices Datuk Nadzarin Wok Nordin and Datuk Amarjeet Singh, dismissed the appeal unanimously and ordered Mohammad Nabill Sajid Mohammad Aslam Sajid to pay RM30,000 in costs.

Justice Shahnaz said the trial judge made no appealable error in assessing the medical evidence and had found that the defendants acted in accordance with accepted medical practice, Free Malaysia Today noted.

She said the applicable standard in medical damages cases is that of a reasonable and competent medical practitioner.

“Differences in medical opinion do not amount to medical negligence if treatment is supported by a reasonable body of medical opinion. What this entails is that a doctor is not negligent merely because another doctor would have acted differently,” she said.

That reasoning rests on the Bolam test, the principle that a doctor is judged against a responsible body of medical opinion rather than against the view of a single expert who would have chosen another course.

The case arose from a road accident on 11 July 2020, when Mohammad Nabill was 21. He sustained an incomplete spinal cord injury, several spinal fractures, lung injuries and rib fractures, and was admitted to the hospital’s intensive care unit.

He underwent spinal surgery on 15 July, four days after the accident. He argued that the delay in carrying out decompression surgery left him with permanent tetraplegia, and that the doctors did not obtain proper informed consent or explain the risks of waiting.

The defendants said they followed professional standards and standard clinical operating procedures at all times, and that he was not stable enough for decompression surgery at that stage. Their case was that other traumatic injuries and haemodynamic instability made immediate spinal surgery inadvisable, and that stabilising him came before definitive fixation.

He had sought RM400,000 in general damages for pain and suffering and loss of amenities, RM2,943,078 for nursing care, RM212,726 for loss of income, RM701,600 for a disable-friendly motor vehicle, RM58,912 for modifications to his house, RM29,005 in special damages and RM500,000 in aggravated damages. The items add up to RM4,845,321.

The High Court dismissed the suit in April 2025 after finding no breach of duty of care. It held that the treatment was supported by a responsible body of medical opinion, and that Mohammad Nabill had not shown that the alleged negligence caused his paralysis, which the court attributed to the injuries from the crash.

The High Court assessed damages at RM4.14 million, the sum it would have awarded had liability been established.

Datuk M. Karuppanan and M. Diveena appeared for Mohammad Nabill. Senior federal counsel Mohd ‘Afif Ali and Federal Counsel Amirul Hisyam Azedi Noor appeared for the government and the hospital staff.

Look here 👇

Join our Channels on Whatsapp & Telegram
Like our Facebook Page 👉🏻 PenangToday
Join our Facebook Group 👉🏻 PenangToday Community
Follow our Instagram 👉🏻 @penangtoday
We are on TikTok 👉🏻 @penang2day
Gotta cover LinkedIn 👉🏻 PenangToday
Our Threads be like 👉🏻 @penangtoday
Get on our X 👉🏻 @penang2day
Here's our Youtube 👉🏻 PenangToday

Related

Latest

Popular